Ellen’s mother was looked down upon by the servants and she’s letting the same thing happen to Ruby instead of trying to help?!?
Ellen is in the wrong no matter how you look at it she didn’t even bother to try and ask her brother for help.
Ellen only has herself to blame for her suffering If she goes and tries to act buddy buddy with our Ruby after what she DID…
I WILL PERSONALLY SEND HER TO MEET HER MOTHER …..😌🙃
Ellen is in the wrong she’s just using her mother and trauma as a scapegoat.
Everyone who is defending Ellen probably didn’t read properly.
Ellen knows Ruby suffers from something similar to her mother’s condition but instead of helping her she sides with the made who abuses her.
WHO THE FUCK DOES THAT?!?!
I FEEL BAD FOR THE MALE LEAD …
I am very confused about people mentioning how the Maid is trying to protect Ellen and the family by bullying/abusing Ruby and how it’s okay for Ellen to protect her. I understand that the head Maid was the emotional and maternal support of Ellen growing up but they are all adults here and the abuse she is perpetrating against Ruby is unjustified. As a consequence she should be punished, I don’t know if execution is under or overboard but I due believe it is well within Iske’s right to punish the Maid as he sees fit. And Ellen needs to see that while she has a deep bond with the Maid she can not enable her to treat Ruby the same way her mother treated her. Also, someone mentioned that Ruby’s eating disorder should have never been disclosed without her knowledge and that is true and part of the problem. This chapter is infuriating to say the least. WTF!
Now I hate her, she became the 3rd character from this story whom I will not love now. It’s kind of disgusting. Of course, I understand everything, but all the same, in this situation, as for me, she did not act correctly.
Honestly Ellen is acting as if she is the only one who suffered from the death of their mother and while I understand that Marta had been there for Ellen while their mother was suffering with an ED, that still doesn’t change the fact that Ruby is the lady of the house and should not have been disrespected like that by a maid, prior nanny or not. In that time it would be completely accepted and even expected for Izek to punish Marta by killing her for disrespecting his wife like that as they are nearly on equal standing and it would have set a good example so that none of the other staff members would consider following in Marta’s footsteps. Ellen keeps feeling sorry for herself and protecting Marta but I believe that if she refuses to allow Marta to be executed for her crimes then she should happily allow Marta to at least be stripped of her position for her crimes which consist of MULTIPLE MURDER ATTEMPTS such as the first night with the light and the sand in the drink. Not to mention Ellen keeps acting as if she is the only one being harmed by other people’s eating disorder and not even the people suffering from the disorder themselves. I’ve noticed that when she talks about her mother and her ED she always seems to bring the attention to how Ellen suffered from her mother having an ED and while I understand that seeing loved ones suffering hurts you she always seemed to remember her mother as some sort of sporadic monster and not as an actual person who was suffering.
I FUCKING HATE ELLEN she keeps telling everyone about Ruby’s anorexia w/o the persons consent and act like shes the most miserable person on this planet!! YOURE NOT THE ONLY WHO HAS TRAUMA GET OVER YOURSELF JFC 💀💀💀 talked like her brother himself also didnt witness their mother death, she even had the audacity to admit she was happy Ruby was the one who had to marry her family so she didnt have to be the one to go to another country alone, AND YET SHE STILL TREATS RUBY LIKE TRASH SHES JUST AS HORRIBLE AS FREYA except she puts up a “i care for you” sister act in front of people!!!
Shut the fuck up , it’s not Ellen’s fault that she protected that b*tchy maid, ugh! why can’t you understand her? You should blame that fuckin evil Bitch maid because she had the AUDACITY to use Ellen to escape from Him, Ugh Thank God The Ml is not as dumb as this mf
I am very disappointed in Ellen. She knows that Ruby is suffering from something similar to her mother and instead of feeling that compassion that maybe she could help Ruby, she decided to side with Marta. I also understand that marta was a mother figure to Ellen but that still does not justify what Marta did and Ellen should at least opt for a light warning instead of beheading in the very least as a warning. Ontop of all that she hurts her brother by blaming him for being busy whilst she suffered in silence wich is now causing him trauma and emotional distress. Wow Ellen. That was just Unjust. 🫤🫤
No one can change my mind. I hate Ellen in this part. I was disapppinted on how everything came out. She should atleast stood up for Ruby, i know she only met ruby and their bond is not as deep as with marta. But she knowa how weak ruby’s mind yet she cried like that over someone who’s bullying her. I wanna cry, i also have the same issue as ruby and their mother. And as for someone who suffers like that, this chapter is a huge disppointment. Sorry, the story is good. But the issue wasn’t completely explained. Like why theit mother do that and it’s all about ellen. Like how it happened in real life, no body listened to us. Yes, they were silently there wheb we were talking, acting like they were listening. But when problem resurface and we tries to fight, it’s all on us. It’s all our fault. It’s because we can’t think right, ut’s because we don’t logically thinking. But it’s not. People knows the problem, and they are usung that problem to victimize themselves. Sorry, i know some understand ellen. But i can’t. I just can’t. As a victim of the twisted judgement of society, i will say this. Stop putting the blame on those who are already a victim and start claiming your fault. In this case, ellen just made EVERYONE knew about ruby’s case. And nade EVERYONE think that they can put a blame on ruby’s illness. That actually happened to me… And hopefully the duke will have a better judgement and take ruby away from there. I, almost lost my life because of that kind of case, and that happened january 13, 2015. I tried to took my own life because of the blaming, shaming, insecurities, painful remarks and sneers. That was painful, specially in how no one tried to stop them laugjung at me. Sorry i jyst wanna share it.
I like how complex this story is. As much as you try to sway it this way or the other, no one is completely in the right. Marta is an absolute b*tch, we can likely all agree. But she did do a good deed of saving Ellen and being a mother figure for her. The ML did have a right to kill her but as did Ellen, trying to save the person who protected, raised, and saved her. I don’t think she should get off for free, though. She should at least lose a limb, be banished or something else imo.
Yall protecting marta saying she is the mother figure to ellen like- why ruby needs to suffer from their actions ? Ruby hasn’t hurt anyone like their mother did. And marta should know her place. Ruby is the duchess. She is the maid.
She hasn’t done anything to ellen. But RUBY THE ONLY ONE WHO SUFFER, start with marta, then freya and her bro and now ellen.
If you wanna backup marta saying she is the mother figure to ellen, then you need to check on ruby. She’s being used by her father, brother and now coming to the duke house- knowing that nobody welcome her, being accused putting poison, being accused mad at freya and more. Just how sick is that.
If ellen wants to protect ruby or whatsoever, talk to her like izek ask her what’s going on. Imagine if izek didn’t take action? The maid and others gonna disrespect her.
Totally bullshit. Their characters are making me on the edge istg.
just as expected Ruby isn’t safe there
as much as she suffered from her ill mom
she’s encouraging others to do the same
like she’s allowing others to bully fl
not allowing ml to punish either.
and Ppl who think ml sister is pitful it’s between ml and his sister y should Ruby suffer?
While I understand that Marta is an extremely important mother figure for Ellen, this goes beyond that. Rubi is the Madam of the House. ( I don’t completely hate Ellen, and I do understand where she’s coming from. She’s a very complex character. Please understand that as you read this.)
Marta knew exactly what she was doing to Rubi, and knew the punishment that could happed. She also knew that Ellen would try and protect her. She used her position as Head Maid to bully and threaten Rubi. Putting sand in Rubi’s drink alone would have been enough to be executed. Let’s also not forget Rubi’s very FIRST night, where Marta purposely let the fire in Rubi’s room go out. This is a blatant act of attempted murder.
The fact that Ellen, who is just the sister of Izek, the heir of the Duchy, gave orders to the servants OVER him, is just plain disrespectful. While she is a noble of high rank and is the older sibling, like it or not, Izek has more authority and is the Lord of the House. He’s too soft with her, imo.
Continuing on, fit of rage or not, Izek was completely in the right to execute Marta. It’s extreme by our standards and not something I condone, but in this setting and timeframe, it’s completely correct.
In Izek’s eyes, Marta has disrespected his wife (who is, again, the Lady of the House and is of nearly equal rank to him). At this point he doesn’t even know about the sand incident. Making an example of Marta in front of the other servants would show that he and Rubi are very close, and that by harming her you can and will face severe consequences. This would encourage them to stay on Rubi’s good side at all times.
That being, said, I know from spoilers and the novel what happens with Marta, and imo she gets off way too easily for everything she’s done so far.
I understand that Ellen wants the maid to be alive but why does the maid hate rubi tho is it because she has the same sickness as the mom and she thinks that rubi is or will be like her? It doesn’t matter to me if the maid is alive or not I just don’t want her to bother rubi, but poor Ellen even if her mother was ill and she knew that, she was still her mother and wanted to kill her, in her eyes as a kid who had no one else it hurts
Does no one understand psychology??? The late Duchess was mentally unstable. For the young Ellen, her nanny was her sole caregiver, her emotional support. The nanny was someone that took care of her when she was young and needed love from a maternal figure. You should try to understand how much trust she have for the nanny who was with her throughout the years. Ellen is emotionally attached to the nanny just how anyone would to someone who shows them affection. That’s normal.
NAH CUZ ELLEN IS PISSING ME OFF. I JUST KNOE THEY WILL GO BACK TO HER ROOM, ELLEN WILL CRY IN HER NANNY’S LAP AND THEY WILL LIVE HAPPILY EVER AFTER W BUTTERFLIES AND RAINBOWS. R U JUST NOT GONNA APOLOGIZE TO THE FL? WHAT ABT THE FACT THAT THE NANNY LITERALLY LIED AND DENIED IT? ELLEN UR A GROWN ASS FUCKING WOMAN GET S GRIP NOBOYD GIVED A SHIT ABT UR MOMMY ISSUES
people often overlook how much Izek loves his sister, in the picture that talked about Ellen marrying Enzo if ruby didn’t marry Izek, he looked pretty p*ssed
and not to mention Izek only hung out with Freya and her brother because Ellen told him too
and he held her hand when their mother died
SO she decided to tell the maid that made put motherfucking SAND in Ruby’s drink told our poor fl some bullshit that drove her to run away got away with it but yet decided to repeat her actions AGAIN because you told her about ruby’s eating disorder and problems how stupider can U get KILL THE DAMN MAID OR ILL REINCARNATE AND KILL HER MYSELF!
God you guys are horrible people she fucked up yes but death penalty? What’s wrong with yall Marta is like her mother she saw her get hurt over and over again as a child and impulsively did somthing horrible but that doesn’t mean she’s a bad person just someone who did a bad thing. Yes I agree she should have gotten punished for example banished to some palace for a month or somthing it makes me so angry yall are saying she should be dead absolutely not get over it she made a mistake
she didn’t make “a mistake” she is doing all this since the beginning and she KNOWS that it is wrong and that this type of “mistake” can be punished with death. she just also knows that she will be protected by ellen and that’s why she LIED when the sister asked her if she did it, bc she knew it was wrong but she also knew she could manipulate ellen and get away with it. she is not a good person that made one mistake, she is a bad person that made one good action and now thinks she can do whatever she wants because ellen owns her.
Don’t be too bothered by it. People always lack nuance when it comes to side characters. It’s a tragic situation all around, Ruby is being bullied by Ellen’s maid who happens to be her mother figure who protected her from abuse. But since Ellen is not the MC and talks about why she can’t just let her brother kill her in fit of (understable) rage nobody gives a shit and therefore Ellen is a “bad character”.Even though her reactions are completely realistic (which is why I love this manwha). People are too used to side characters who kiss the ground the MCs walk on and kill their own family in a heartbeat for MCs they met 2 weeks ago. So I’m not even surprised by this comment section 🙄
It’s a different world, different society. This maid knew “exactly” what the potential consequences would be. She just became incredibly arrogant with her position.
That’s why she was lying about what she said.
She knew it was a death sentence to be that disrespectful to the madam of the house.
She was also bullying the FL throughout the story and lying constantly.
The party the ML supposedly didn’t want her to attend?
As a modern person, of course the death sentence seems extreme, but that was the reality in those kinds of societies, and the maid was fully aware of what her actions could cause.
idc what ellen says, the maid put fucking sand in rubys drink and said all that stuff to her, being good to one person doesnt make you a good person. but being horrible to even one human being does make her a garbage little shit so OFF WITH HER FUCKIUNG HEAD
Ellen really lacks communication. Honey, no one will know or understand you until you talk.
It’s admirable that Marta went against her mistress to save Ellen. But that doesn’t undo her cruelness and rudeness towards Ruby, she still should be punished, just maybe not by death. Else she will have an “I can do whatever I want because Miss Ellen will always protect me” mindset.
Also, I really dislike how Ellen compares Ruby with her mother as if she treats them as the same person. They have similar eating disorders, but not all mental illnesses and personalities. But she punishes Ruby in her mind for what he mother did. Like “My mother was absolutely nuts and I couldn’t trust even a single word she said, she also was violent towards me. Ruby and my mother have the same eating disorder, so Ruby must be just as violent and trust-unworthy” or something. And yes, trauma… but that’s still unfair.
And that “Marta is important to me, so you must respect that, brother. I know Ruby is important to you, but I’ll respect it only when it’s convenient to me and doesn’t hurt my little world.” is… idk, disappointing.
It’s really funny and unfair that you say that Ellen lacks communication regarding her abuse. When using your logic the same thing could be said to Ruby 🫤 but that would be fucked up because ofc people don’t always react perfectly and do the right things because of trauma
PPL seem to forget how evryone is forgetting Ruby is getting bullied to point girl ran away and is getting simple water with sand in it
to a bitch manipulating everyone against her
and here Ellen is talking about her personal trauma to save the nanny who wanted to seperate fl and ml
lol, im with u tho, but i think it would be better to let her off one LAST time, if she still dont do right then off with her head immediantly! or a livving hell bc it will make her( headmaid) ssuffer
Well sorry this has nothing to do with wht she is dng now she has been trying to get ruby killed or kicked outsince day 1 she is a old women who thinks she is not just a nanny and acts like owner and this is nthg
Wht would ellen do if she was sent if ruby dint acceptto marry iz it would be her there is south sturggling and they are crazy dangerous ppl.
And ellem will keep disappointing us wit multiple misunderstanding she will never support ruby untill she knows wht her brother was dng so basically she is someone who will not belive u until u die if thst day ruby died these ppl would just sit and be upset any way that way in future to happen
squidward supremacy
i am loving the comments rn like hell yea keep them essays coming!!
I love hot men
Ellen’s mother was looked down upon by the servants and she’s letting the same thing happen to Ruby instead of trying to help?!?
Ellen is in the wrong no matter how you look at it she didn’t even bother to try and ask her brother for help.
Ellen only has herself to blame for her suffering If she goes and tries to act buddy buddy with our Ruby after what she DID…
I WILL PERSONALLY SEND HER TO MEET HER MOTHER …..😌🙃
I love hot men
Ellen is in the wrong she’s just using her mother and trauma as a scapegoat.
Everyone who is defending Ellen probably didn’t read properly.
Ellen knows Ruby suffers from something similar to her mother’s condition but instead of helping her she sides with the made who abuses her.
WHO THE FUCK DOES THAT?!?!
I FEEL BAD FOR THE MALE LEAD …
rlduncan127
I am very confused about people mentioning how the Maid is trying to protect Ellen and the family by bullying/abusing Ruby and how it’s okay for Ellen to protect her. I understand that the head Maid was the emotional and maternal support of Ellen growing up but they are all adults here and the abuse she is perpetrating against Ruby is unjustified. As a consequence she should be punished, I don’t know if execution is under or overboard but I due believe it is well within Iske’s right to punish the Maid as he sees fit. And Ellen needs to see that while she has a deep bond with the Maid she can not enable her to treat Ruby the same way her mother treated her. Also, someone mentioned that Ruby’s eating disorder should have never been disclosed without her knowledge and that is true and part of the problem. This chapter is infuriating to say the least. WTF!
Hierarchy
Now I hate her, she became the 3rd character from this story whom I will not love now. It’s kind of disgusting. Of course, I understand everything, but all the same, in this situation, as for me, she did not act correctly.
Derpiest_Unicorn
Honestly Ellen is acting as if she is the only one who suffered from the death of their mother and while I understand that Marta had been there for Ellen while their mother was suffering with an ED, that still doesn’t change the fact that Ruby is the lady of the house and should not have been disrespected like that by a maid, prior nanny or not. In that time it would be completely accepted and even expected for Izek to punish Marta by killing her for disrespecting his wife like that as they are nearly on equal standing and it would have set a good example so that none of the other staff members would consider following in Marta’s footsteps. Ellen keeps feeling sorry for herself and protecting Marta but I believe that if she refuses to allow Marta to be executed for her crimes then she should happily allow Marta to at least be stripped of her position for her crimes which consist of MULTIPLE MURDER ATTEMPTS such as the first night with the light and the sand in the drink. Not to mention Ellen keeps acting as if she is the only one being harmed by other people’s eating disorder and not even the people suffering from the disorder themselves. I’ve noticed that when she talks about her mother and her ED she always seems to bring the attention to how Ellen suffered from her mother having an ED and while I understand that seeing loved ones suffering hurts you she always seemed to remember her mother as some sort of sporadic monster and not as an actual person who was suffering.
We have progessed past the need for obssesive ML
I FUCKING HATE ELLEN she keeps telling everyone about Ruby’s anorexia w/o the persons consent and act like shes the most miserable person on this planet!! YOURE NOT THE ONLY WHO HAS TRAUMA GET OVER YOURSELF JFC 💀💀💀 talked like her brother himself also didnt witness their mother death, she even had the audacity to admit she was happy Ruby was the one who had to marry her family so she didnt have to be the one to go to another country alone, AND YET SHE STILL TREATS RUBY LIKE TRASH SHES JUST AS HORRIBLE AS FREYA except she puts up a “i care for you” sister act in front of people!!!
im_not
Shut the fuck up , it’s not Ellen’s fault that she protected that b*tchy maid, ugh! why can’t you understand her? You should blame that fuckin evil Bitch maid because she had the AUDACITY to use Ellen to escape from Him, Ugh Thank God The Ml is not as dumb as this mf
tigress
What the maid did and what Ellen did are two completely different things. Stop looking for a scapegoat to protect Ellen.
CallMeOP
The thing I liked the most is the whole amount of commentaries that are almost book chapter’s lenght. I just love it
Todi_02
Lovely isnt it 🥹
LoveEmAll
I am very disappointed in Ellen. She knows that Ruby is suffering from something similar to her mother and instead of feeling that compassion that maybe she could help Ruby, she decided to side with Marta. I also understand that marta was a mother figure to Ellen but that still does not justify what Marta did and Ellen should at least opt for a light warning instead of beheading in the very least as a warning. Ontop of all that she hurts her brother by blaming him for being busy whilst she suffered in silence wich is now causing him trauma and emotional distress. Wow Ellen. That was just Unjust. 🫤🫤
I_simp_abs
No one can change my mind. I hate Ellen in this part. I was disapppinted on how everything came out. She should atleast stood up for Ruby, i know she only met ruby and their bond is not as deep as with marta. But she knowa how weak ruby’s mind yet she cried like that over someone who’s bullying her. I wanna cry, i also have the same issue as ruby and their mother. And as for someone who suffers like that, this chapter is a huge disppointment. Sorry, the story is good. But the issue wasn’t completely explained. Like why theit mother do that and it’s all about ellen. Like how it happened in real life, no body listened to us. Yes, they were silently there wheb we were talking, acting like they were listening. But when problem resurface and we tries to fight, it’s all on us. It’s all our fault. It’s because we can’t think right, ut’s because we don’t logically thinking. But it’s not. People knows the problem, and they are usung that problem to victimize themselves. Sorry, i know some understand ellen. But i can’t. I just can’t. As a victim of the twisted judgement of society, i will say this. Stop putting the blame on those who are already a victim and start claiming your fault. In this case, ellen just made EVERYONE knew about ruby’s case. And nade EVERYONE think that they can put a blame on ruby’s illness. That actually happened to me… And hopefully the duke will have a better judgement and take ruby away from there. I, almost lost my life because of that kind of case, and that happened january 13, 2015. I tried to took my own life because of the blaming, shaming, insecurities, painful remarks and sneers. That was painful, specially in how no one tried to stop them laugjung at me. Sorry i jyst wanna share it.
Darren090909
I like how complex this story is. As much as you try to sway it this way or the other, no one is completely in the right. Marta is an absolute b*tch, we can likely all agree. But she did do a good deed of saving Ellen and being a mother figure for her. The ML did have a right to kill her but as did Ellen, trying to save the person who protected, raised, and saved her. I don’t think she should get off for free, though. She should at least lose a limb, be banished or something else imo.
Cookie_monster
Yall protecting marta saying she is the mother figure to ellen like- why ruby needs to suffer from their actions ? Ruby hasn’t hurt anyone like their mother did. And marta should know her place. Ruby is the duchess. She is the maid.
She hasn’t done anything to ellen. But RUBY THE ONLY ONE WHO SUFFER, start with marta, then freya and her bro and now ellen.
If you wanna backup marta saying she is the mother figure to ellen, then you need to check on ruby. She’s being used by her father, brother and now coming to the duke house- knowing that nobody welcome her, being accused putting poison, being accused mad at freya and more. Just how sick is that.
If ellen wants to protect ruby or whatsoever, talk to her like izek ask her what’s going on. Imagine if izek didn’t take action? The maid and others gonna disrespect her.
Totally bullshit. Their characters are making me on the edge istg.
im_not
Ikr 🙄 their making me on edge too you’re not alone darling
The Head Of Armed forces Of Zelink
she probably manipulated her
Hanine
exactly she probably did this earlier to protect her self with Ellen now .
trucksama
just as expected Ruby isn’t safe there
as much as she suffered from her ill mom
she’s encouraging others to do the same
like she’s allowing others to bully fl
not allowing ml to punish either.
and Ppl who think ml sister is pitful it’s between ml and his sister y should Ruby suffer?
serine
sht this is so devastatinggg
the maid still needs punishment for blabbing her mouth tho ughh
singularity0613
While I understand that Marta is an extremely important mother figure for Ellen, this goes beyond that. Rubi is the Madam of the House. ( I don’t completely hate Ellen, and I do understand where she’s coming from. She’s a very complex character. Please understand that as you read this.)
Marta knew exactly what she was doing to Rubi, and knew the punishment that could happed. She also knew that Ellen would try and protect her. She used her position as Head Maid to bully and threaten Rubi. Putting sand in Rubi’s drink alone would have been enough to be executed. Let’s also not forget Rubi’s very FIRST night, where Marta purposely let the fire in Rubi’s room go out. This is a blatant act of attempted murder.
The fact that Ellen, who is just the sister of Izek, the heir of the Duchy, gave orders to the servants OVER him, is just plain disrespectful. While she is a noble of high rank and is the older sibling, like it or not, Izek has more authority and is the Lord of the House. He’s too soft with her, imo.
Continuing on, fit of rage or not, Izek was completely in the right to execute Marta. It’s extreme by our standards and not something I condone, but in this setting and timeframe, it’s completely correct.
In Izek’s eyes, Marta has disrespected his wife (who is, again, the Lady of the House and is of nearly equal rank to him). At this point he doesn’t even know about the sand incident. Making an example of Marta in front of the other servants would show that he and Rubi are very close, and that by harming her you can and will face severe consequences. This would encourage them to stay on Rubi’s good side at all times.
That being, said, I know from spoilers and the novel what happens with Marta, and imo she gets off way too easily for everything she’s done so far.
The_Qxan_Bean
I understand that Ellen wants the maid to be alive but why does the maid hate rubi tho is it because she has the same sickness as the mom and she thinks that rubi is or will be like her? It doesn’t matter to me if the maid is alive or not I just don’t want her to bother rubi, but poor Ellen even if her mother was ill and she knew that, she was still her mother and wanted to kill her, in her eyes as a kid who had no one else it hurts
I am a simp
Well i dont see anything wrong with ellen protecting the maid fight me if u want but i wont complaint about anything
Namjoon's left tiddy
Not maybe a death sentence but that maid should be banished and Ellen and that maid should apologise to the fl
mother of shitzhus
Protect ze honor!
mitsumi
Does no one understand psychology??? The late Duchess was mentally unstable. For the young Ellen, her nanny was her sole caregiver, her emotional support. The nanny was someone that took care of her when she was young and needed love from a maternal figure. You should try to understand how much trust she have for the nanny who was with her throughout the years. Ellen is emotionally attached to the nanny just how anyone would to someone who shows them affection. That’s normal.
kurspuku_2
я розчарована😃
Virgo999
Na the sister should investigate and keep a VERY close eye on Marta.
I hate this site bro
NAH CUZ ELLEN IS PISSING ME OFF. I JUST KNOE THEY WILL GO BACK TO HER ROOM, ELLEN WILL CRY IN HER NANNY’S LAP AND THEY WILL LIVE HAPPILY EVER AFTER W BUTTERFLIES AND RAINBOWS. R U JUST NOT GONNA APOLOGIZE TO THE FL? WHAT ABT THE FACT THAT THE NANNY LITERALLY LIED AND DENIED IT? ELLEN UR A GROWN ASS FUCKING WOMAN GET S GRIP NOBOYD GIVED A SHIT ABT UR MOMMY ISSUES
KiwiBear
people often overlook how much Izek loves his sister, in the picture that talked about Ellen marrying Enzo if ruby didn’t marry Izek, he looked pretty p*ssed
and not to mention Izek only hung out with Freya and her brother because Ellen told him too
and he held her hand when their mother died
izzy.not.again
SO she decided to tell the maid that made put motherfucking SAND in Ruby’s drink told our poor fl some bullshit that drove her to run away got away with it but yet decided to repeat her actions AGAIN because you told her about ruby’s eating disorder and problems how stupider can U get KILL THE DAMN MAID OR ILL REINCARNATE AND KILL HER MYSELF!
dont touch the fl or ur going to hell with me
i say just throw that bitch out :shrug:
Ellazzz
God you guys are horrible people she fucked up yes but death penalty? What’s wrong with yall Marta is like her mother she saw her get hurt over and over again as a child and impulsively did somthing horrible but that doesn’t mean she’s a bad person just someone who did a bad thing. Yes I agree she should have gotten punished for example banished to some palace for a month or somthing it makes me so angry yall are saying she should be dead absolutely not get over it she made a mistake
user3213456886
she didn’t make “a mistake” she is doing all this since the beginning and she KNOWS that it is wrong and that this type of “mistake” can be punished with death. she just also knows that she will be protected by ellen and that’s why she LIED when the sister asked her if she did it, bc she knew it was wrong but she also knew she could manipulate ellen and get away with it. she is not a good person that made one mistake, she is a bad person that made one good action and now thinks she can do whatever she wants because ellen owns her.
user3213456886
owes *
Furiae19
Don’t be too bothered by it. People always lack nuance when it comes to side characters. It’s a tragic situation all around, Ruby is being bullied by Ellen’s maid who happens to be her mother figure who protected her from abuse. But since Ellen is not the MC and talks about why she can’t just let her brother kill her in fit of (understable) rage nobody gives a shit and therefore Ellen is a “bad character”.Even though her reactions are completely realistic (which is why I love this manwha). People are too used to side characters who kiss the ground the MCs walk on and kill their own family in a heartbeat for MCs they met 2 weeks ago. So I’m not even surprised by this comment section 🙄
OldLadyAnime
It’s a different world, different society. This maid knew “exactly” what the potential consequences would be. She just became incredibly arrogant with her position.
That’s why she was lying about what she said.
She knew it was a death sentence to be that disrespectful to the madam of the house.
She was also bullying the FL throughout the story and lying constantly.
The party the ML supposedly didn’t want her to attend?
As a modern person, of course the death sentence seems extreme, but that was the reality in those kinds of societies, and the maid was fully aware of what her actions could cause.
Satan
BOOOOOOOOOOOOO I WANT HER FUCKING DEAD
Dream on
So?!!!!!! No one’s gonna talk how Ellen called ‘Butler’- a “Rattler”.💀💀
IM HERE TO FIND A HANDSOME MAN
lmao
Starlight ✨
Dw, as I remember ellen will just kick her out. She simply can’t kill her but doesn’t mean she will let her stay anymore
uglysquid1864
idc what ellen says, the maid put fucking sand in rubys drink and said all that stuff to her, being good to one person doesnt make you a good person. but being horrible to even one human being does make her a garbage little shit so OFF WITH HER FUCKIUNG HEAD
Arabanana
Ellen really lacks communication. Honey, no one will know or understand you until you talk.
It’s admirable that Marta went against her mistress to save Ellen. But that doesn’t undo her cruelness and rudeness towards Ruby, she still should be punished, just maybe not by death. Else she will have an “I can do whatever I want because Miss Ellen will always protect me” mindset.
Also, I really dislike how Ellen compares Ruby with her mother as if she treats them as the same person. They have similar eating disorders, but not all mental illnesses and personalities. But she punishes Ruby in her mind for what he mother did. Like “My mother was absolutely nuts and I couldn’t trust even a single word she said, she also was violent towards me. Ruby and my mother have the same eating disorder, so Ruby must be just as violent and trust-unworthy” or something. And yes, trauma… but that’s still unfair.
And that “Marta is important to me, so you must respect that, brother. I know Ruby is important to you, but I’ll respect it only when it’s convenient to me and doesn’t hurt my little world.” is… idk, disappointing.
Furiae19
It’s really funny and unfair that you say that Ellen lacks communication regarding her abuse. When using your logic the same thing could be said to Ruby 🫤 but that would be fucked up because ofc people don’t always react perfectly and do the right things because of trauma
trucksama
just commented same thing lol
PPL seem to forget how evryone is forgetting Ruby is getting bullied to point girl ran away and is getting simple water with sand in it
to a bitch manipulating everyone against her
and here Ellen is talking about her personal trauma to save the nanny who wanted to seperate fl and ml
like what was Ruby fault in this tho ….
Luitch
Idc off with her head 🗣🗣
Palicel
lol, im with u tho, but i think it would be better to let her off one LAST time, if she still dont do right then off with her head immediantly! or a livving hell bc it will make her( headmaid) ssuffer
ran
sighs
Hiiii
Well sorry this has nothing to do with wht she is dng now she has been trying to get ruby killed or kicked outsince day 1 she is a old women who thinks she is not just a nanny and acts like owner and this is nthg
Wht would ellen do if she was sent if ruby dint acceptto marry iz it would be her there is south sturggling and they are crazy dangerous ppl.
And ellem will keep disappointing us wit multiple misunderstanding she will never support ruby untill she knows wht her brother was dng so basically she is someone who will not belive u until u die if thst day ruby died these ppl would just sit and be upset any way that way in future to happen
KillMyDay
i just got a stroke from reading your comment
Nothing
Sheeesh…
can't wait for my things to get wiped again
marta still should be kicked out or out right banished from the north
Ellazzz
The sister ain’t stupid she’s just going through a lot trauma effects so so much especially how you deal with stress and tough situations
argue with the wall
REAL
argue with the wall
she gagged him bro is rash asf
Potan
well…..I still don’t like Ellen for whatever the reason is 🙂 just irritated
bingereader
At least kick her out ughh
Otakumami
The sister is stupid
P10F 2.0
yummy conflict